What Actually Is a Brand? (Not What Your Marketing Agency Tells You)
The Brand Confusion Epidemic (And Why It's Getting Worse)
TLDR
A brand isn't your logo, colors, or tagline - it's the gut feeling people get about your business. It's the emotional aftertaste that lingers after someone interacts with you. I've spent years watching businesses waste millions on "branding" while ignoring what actually matters: the consistent experience that builds trust. Strong brands are valuable because they create shortcuts to purchase decisions, command premium prices, and attract loyal customers naturally. Most businesses focus on looking good rather than being good. Stop obsessing over your logo and start obsessing over how you make people feel.
The Brand Confusion Epidemic (And Why It's Getting Worse)
This conversation happens in boardrooms every day:
Founder: "We need to work on our brand."
Me: "Great, what specifically about your brand needs work?"
Founder: "You know... our brand. The logo, the colors, maybe a tagline. The brand stuff."
Internal sigh.
The problem isn't that founders are stupid—they're often brilliant. It's that we've all been fed a superficial definition of "brand" by an industry that profits from making it seem more complicated and more visual than it actually is.
Let me be brutally clear:
Your logo is not your brand
Your color palette is not your brand
Your fancy business cards are not your brand
Your "brand guidelines" PDF is not your brand
Those are all brand accessories - the earrings, not the person. Important? Sure. The main event? Not even close.
What a Brand Actually Is (From Someone Who's Built a Few)
Here's my definition after building and revamping brands for 15 years:
Your brand is the aftertaste you leave in people's mouths after they interact with your business in any way.
It's the feeling that lingers. The emotional residue. The gut reaction when someone sees, hears, or thinks about your company.
Starbucks isn't a brand because they have a green mermaid logo. They're a brand because they've created a consistent "third place" feeling between home and work—the same feeling whether you're in Seattle or Shanghai.
When someone says, "That's such a Nike thing to do," they're not talking about the swoosh. They're talking about the attitude, the stance, the vibe that Nike has cultivated over decades.
Brand as a Relationship (Not an Asset)
Let's try a more human metaphor: Your brand is like a relationship with thousands or millions of people at once.
Think about your closest friend. What makes that friendship valuable?
It's not their appearance (though you recognize them instantly)
It's not their name (though that's how you refer to them)
It's not their clothing style (though it might reflect their personality)
It's the consistent way they make you feel, the trust you've built, the values you share, and the experiences you've had together.
That's your brand—a relationship at scale.
The Four Elements of Brands That Actually Work
If we strip away the design agencies' mystique, strong brands consistently nail four things:
1. Reputation: The Stories People Tell About You
Your reputation isn't what you claim - it's what others say when you're not in the room.
I once worked with a luxury hotel that spent millions on stunning visual branding but ignored hundreds of terrible reviews about rude staff. Their reputation (the stories people told) completely undermined their visual brand.
Reputation is built through:
Actual customer experiences (not promised ones)
How you handle mistakes
The values you demonstrate (not just proclaim)
The company you keep (partners, investors, customers)
A fancy logo won't fix a shitty reputation. Just ask Wells Fargo or Facebook.
2. Recognition: The Patterns People Associate With You
Recognition goes far beyond visuals. It's the consistent patterns that trigger people to think, "Oh, that's [your company]!"
Southwest Airlines' recognition comes from humor, friendly service, and no-frills efficiency—not their (frankly forgettable) logo.
Recognition elements include:
Visual markers (yes, including that logo)
Voice and communication style
Predictable behaviors and policies
Distinctive product features
Service patterns and rituals
The key is consistency. One Southwest flight attendant cracking jokes builds recognition. Thousands doing it over decades builds a brand.
3. Relevance: Why People Should Care About You Today
Brands die when they lose relevance - when they solve yesterday's problems or embody outdated values.
Kodak had universal recognition but lost complete relevance in the digital era. Meanwhile, Netflix has reinvented itself multiple times to stay painfully relevant.
Relevance comes from:
Solving current problems
Reflecting evolving values
Cultural connectedness
Emotional resonance with today's context
The most dangerous brand question: "If you disappeared tomorrow, would anyone genuinely miss you?"
4. Resonance: The Emotional Connection You Create
The most powerful brands create emotional resonance - they make people feel something.
Apple makes you feel creative and distinctive. Patagonia makes you feel environmentally responsible. Harley-Davidson makes you feel rebellious and free.
This emotional connection is the most valuable and least understood aspect of branding. It's why people tattoo Harley logos on their bodies but not HP logos.
Resonance can't be faked or purchased. It must be earned through consistent experiences that evoke specific emotions.
Brand Confession Booth: Learning The Hard Way
Let me share some real-world lessons that shaped my perspective on branding:
The "Logo Will Fix It" Fallacy I've seen businesses spend five figures on gorgeous visual identities while delivering terrible customer experiences. The result? A beautifully designed failure. No amount of design polish can fix a broken experience.
The "Brand Voice" That Wasn't I once reviewed the brand guidelines for five different SaaS companies in the same industry. All five claimed to have a "friendly, approachable, slightly irreverent" voice. All five were utterly indistinguishable. Having a "friendly voice" isn't a brand—it's a basic expectation.
The Values That Nobody Remembered Almost every company has "brand values" on their website. Ask employees to name them without looking, and you'll get blank stares. Values that live on a wall but not in decisions aren't brand values—they're decorations.
The pattern? Focusing on brand expressions instead of brand experiences.
Why Most Businesses Get Brand Completely Backward
Most businesses build brands like they're assembling a costume, starting with:
Visual identity (logo, colors, fonts)
Verbal identity (tagline, messaging)
Brand guidelines document
This is building a brand from the outside in. It's why so many brands look distinctive but feel generic.
Strong brands build from the inside out:
Purpose and perspective (why you exist, what you believe)
Principles and promises (how you operate, what people can expect)
Personality and presentation (how you express these externally)
Zappos didn't start with a distinctive logo. They started with an obsession with customer service. The external expressions followed the internal reality.
The Truth About Brand and Business Growth
If brand is just "how people feel," why should hardheaded business people care? Because those feelings drive business metrics:
Customer Acquisition: Brands Are Shortcut Machines
In a world drowning in options, strong brands create mental shortcuts to purchase decisions. When Target needs more toilet paper, they don't evaluate 12 suppliers—they call Charmin. That shortcut is worth billions.
I worked with a B2B software company that reduced their sales cycle from 86 days to 41 days as their brand strengthened. Nothing about their product changed—prospects just required less convincing.
Pricing Power: Feelings → Margins
People happily pay more for brands they trust and love. Full stop.
The bottled water industry is the perfect case study. Chemically identical products sell for vastly different prices based entirely on brand perception. Fiji Water costs 280% more than store-brand water because of how it makes people feel.
Talent Attraction: Culture Made Visible
Your brand is a talent magnet or repellent. Strong brands attract people who share their values and repel those who don't - creating a hiring filter that no HR department could match.
I've seen companies reduce recruiting costs by 60%+ with stronger employer branding. The best talent wants to work for companies they admire.
Brand vs. Branding vs. Brand Identity: Ending the Confusion
These terms get tossed around interchangeably, but they're fundamentally different:
Brand: How people feel about your company (exists in their minds)
Branding: The process of shaping those feelings (your actions)
Brand Identity: The symbols that represent those feelings (your expressions)
It's like the difference between your reputation, your behavior, and your signature. They're related but not interchangeable.
The "Naked Brand" Test
Here's my favorite brand exercise with clients: If all your visual and verbal brand elements disappeared overnight - logo, colors, fonts, tagline, everything - would customers still recognize your company through their experiences alone?
Amazon without the smile logo is still Amazon. Ritz-Carlton without the lion logo is still Ritz-Carlton. Most companies without their logos are... anonymous.
If your brand relies entirely on visual identity to be distinctive, you don't have a brand. You have decorations.
Measuring Your Brand Without Million-Dollar Research
Forget fancy brand tracking studies. These simple metrics tell you if your brand is actually working:
The Willing Premium
Simple test: Take your core product and put it next to a competitor's with your logos showing. What percentage more are people willing to pay for yours? That's your brand's financial value.
The Bar Conversation Test
When people learn where you work, do they start telling you about their experiences with your company? The stories they choose reveal your true brand.
I once worked for a major telecom company. Every time I mentioned my employer at parties, people would immediately share their customer service horror stories. No amount of advertising could overcome that reality.
The T-Shirt Test
Would your employees voluntarily wear your company's t-shirt on the weekend? Not for free swag reasons, but because they're proud to be associated with you?
If not, you have an internal brand problem that will eventually become an external one.
Building a Brand That Actually Works
Creating a valuable brand doesn't require a six-figure agency, but it does require honesty, consistency, and patience:
Start with brutal honesty: What do people currently think and feel about you? (Not what you wish they thought)
Define your unique perspective: What do you believe that many others don't?
Make relationship promises: What specific experiences can people count on every time?
Create recognition systems: Develop consistent patterns people can recognize across touchpoints
Live it internally first: Your culture and your brand should be indistinguishable
Express it externally second: Now (and only now) worry about how it looks and sounds
Measure feelings, not just awareness: Track how people feel, not just if they recognize you
A Closing Thought: Logo Last, Not Logo First
The fundamental mistake most companies make is starting with how their brand looks rather than how it feels. They obsess over visual identity before defining emotional identity.
It's like picking out wedding invitations before finding someone to marry.
Your logo should be the last thing you create, not the first. It should capture and express a brand that already exists in how you operate, not define a brand you aspire to build.
Your mission isn't to look different - it's to be different in ways your customers actually value. Do that consistently, and a powerful brand will emerge.
The founder who almost punched me? His company eventually found tremendous success. Their logo today? It's pretty forgettable. Their brand experience? Unforgettable.
And that's the whole point.
Want More Marketing Truth Bombs?
I write about marketing approaches that work in the real world without the agency fluff or consultant doublespeak. If that sounds useful, subscribe for more straight-talk advice on building things that actually work.